Welcome to Community Insurance & Associates

Insuring

Wisconsin since 1925

Insuring Wisconsin since 1925

Specializing in home, auto, life, commercial, and business insurance.

Custom &
Luxury Homes

Cars, Trucks,
Luxury, & Exotics

Individual &
Family Life

Contractors &
Trades

Restaurants &
Bars

Retail Stores
& Shops

Commercial
Properties

Contact Us
To Learn More

Get a quick insurance estimate

Our streamlined process makes it easy to get your Wisconsin insurance policy started. Fill out the quick form and we will reach out to discuss your coverage options.

Wisconsin Insurance

Get insurance
in 3 easy steps

Wisconsin Individuals

Personal Insurance

Community Insurance & Associates provides a wide range of personal insurance options for individuals and families throughout all of Wisconsin.

Homes

It’s important to understand that no two homeowners insurance policies are created equal though. Different insurance companies offer different levels of coverage, conditions and limitations.

We can help you find the best homeowners insurance that will best meet your needs and provide the most valuable combination of coverage, and competitive pricing.

Cars

We can help you with standard auto insurance, as well as car insurance for collector cars. When most people think about car insurance, they think about damage to their car. The truth is, car insurance covers much more than just your car.

Community Insurance & Associates makes the process of finding the best company and price easy.

Life

Life insurance is hands down one of the most cost effective ways to protect the people who depend on you financially. If you have a child, are married, or you are carrying any kind of debt, purchasing life insurance is a no-brainer.

At Community Insurance & Associates, we make the process of buying life insurance extremely simple.

Need insurance for your home, cars, belongings, or family? Community Insurance & Associates is here for you. Click below to start your insurance quote today.

Wisconsin Businesses

Business Insurance

No business is the same, but many companies share common risks. These key commercial insurance policies can help protect your business from common accidents, lawsuits, and damages. Community Insurance & Associates offers an extensive range of business insurance options designed to safeguard your operations, employees, and assets.

Need insurance for your business in Wisconsin?

Service Center

24/7 Access to Everything You Need

Our state-of-the-art portal allows you to locate, and manage your insurance policies quickly. Weeks-long waiting periods and stacks of paperwork are officially obsolete.

Get Policy Changes

Report a Claim

Submit Changes

Request Certificates

Since 1925

About Community Insurance & Associates in Wisconsin

Community Insurance offers insurance solutions for clients residing in Amherst, but our reach extends to all residents in the state of Wisconsin. When it comes to protecting your assets and everything you’ve worked hard to earn, a one-size-fits-all approach is not going to cut it. Let us show you why Community Insurance provides coverage you can count on!

We offer you simple, professional insurance solutions with the support of a qualified and experienced team working on your behalf. Having access to multiple insurance companies gives us the ability to offer you a wide variety of coverage options that can be tailored to your needs and budget. We work for you.

0+

Years in Business

0%

Quality Dedication

0+

Five star reviews

0+

Insurance Carriers

Google Reviews

Client Testimonials

Reviews of our insurance agency speak for themselves. Every customer has a different story to tell based on their individual experience with Community Insurance & Associates. Read some of the reviews online about our Wisconsin insurance agency.

183 S Main St, Amherst

5.0 52 reviews

  • Avatar Tony Kunst ★★★★★ a week ago
    I hadn’t shopped my insurance for awhile. I wanted to add coverages for boat and ATV as well. Kelly was very patient, as I gathered information on everything I needed coverage on. She was prompt with getting everything together for me. … More I’m very happy with how the process went, and I ended up getting the best deal around. I strongly encourage you to reach out to community insurance for all your insurance needs. You might be as surprised as I was!!
  • Avatar MaKynna Lesinski ★★★★★ a month ago
    I was referred to Kelly Loken by a friend, and she has been incredibly helpful. She saved me over $700 on my insurance policies and is always quick to respond. I really appreciate her efficiency and support, highly recommend!
  • Avatar Kim Jezwinski ★★★★★ a month ago
    My recent experience with Kelly Loken at Community Insurance was great! She is quick to respond to inquiries, was patient with my questions and gave good advice regarding specific coverages we were looking at. Very pleased at the overall … More experience and looking forward to working with her and the company in the future.
  • Avatar Ryan Rolf ★★★★★ 3 months ago
    Kelly was great to work with! She was quick to respond and was able to talk me through any questions that I had.
  • Avatar MsGatfly ★★★★★ 10 months ago
    Kelly Loren was quick to get back to us with a solution to our problem. Easy to talk to and pleasant to deal with.
  • Avatar Laura Wheeler ★★★★★ 11 months ago
    Kelly is awesome. Shes very friendly and professional. She helped the bar I work out at big time in obtaining insurance and then getting us a better rate!
  • Avatar Michelle Raddatz ★★★★★ 11 months ago
    We had a good experience with Comminity Insurance. Their Progressive Insurance quote was very reasonable so we made the jump! We have 3 auto and a boat policy through them. We also appreciate that they support highschool seniors with their … More scholarship program!
  • Avatar James Lebouef ★★★★★ 11 months ago
    Kelly is awesome! She has helped with all aspects of personal and business insurance with no problems. Love that I can do business with a human in this day and age. I will always recommend her to anyone for their insurance needs. Certainly … More go to her if you would like to save some money as well.
Blog

Insurance news & money saving tips

If you want to keep up with the latest Wisconsin insurance news stories and headlines, Community Insurance & Associates features an informational blog that covers emerging news and informative insurance-related topics, such as tips and tricks for saving money that may be useful to you; our clients.

Either way, you have come to the right place because our team of experts is ready and waiting to meet your distinct insurance needs.

Latest Articles From Community Insurance & Associates

Follow Us on Instagram

Stay connected with Community Insurance on Instagram @community_ins for helpful insurance tips, real client stories, and updates from our team, see how we protect what matters most in your community.

Every job has risks—but not all coverage is the same.

Understanding what’s included (and what’s not) can make a big difference down the line.

👉 If you’re unsure, it’s always worth a quick review

#ContractorLife #InsuranceTips #BusinessProtection
Today we recognize the anniversary of the United States Army Reserve 🇺🇸

Thank you to those who serve—balancing everyday life while being ready when it matters most.

#ArmyReserve #ThankYouForYourService #CommunityRespect
Game day for our Community Insurance team! ⚽

These little athletes are hitting the field tonight at Jensen Center at 5:45 PM—and we couldn’t be more proud 💚

Good luck out there, have fun, and give it your all!

#GameDay #CommunityFirst #FutureStars @jensen.community.center
Quarterly meeting day 💚

We’re still in the middle of a great afternoon of learning and team time—always focused on how we can continue showing up for our customers.

In honor of Admin Day, we also took a moment to recognize our incredible team with flowers 🌸 Thank you for everything you do to take care of our customers day in and day out.

Special thanks to @acuityinsurance for hosting a CE class with us today!
It’s Earth Day 🌿

It’s easy to feel like you have to do a lot—but small choices add up.

What’s one simple thing you’re doing today? 👇

#EarthDay #DoYourPart #CommunityCare
Quick update—today all of our offices will be closing at 12:30 PM for our quarterly team meeting.

We’ll be back to assist you during regular hours tomorrow. Thank you for your understanding!

#OfficeUpdate #CommunityFirst #HereToHelp
Boat shows are the closest thing to summer this time of year.

A little preview of what’s coming—and something to look forward to.

What's your Lake Day Vibe?

#BoatSeason #SummerVibes #LakeDays
Boat shows are the closest thing to summer this time of year.

A little preview of what’s coming—and something to look forward to.

#BoatSeason #SummerVibes #LakeDays