Google Reviews

Client Testimonials

Reviews of our insurance agency speak for themselves. Every customer has a different story to tell based on their individual experience with Community Insurance & Associates. Read some of the reviews online about our Wisconsin insurance agency.

183 South Main Street, Amherst

5.0 42 reviews

  • Avatar Bob Kirsenlohr ★★★★★ 3 months ago
    I give Eric Martin and Community Isurance five stars! He answered all of our questions found us comapable insurance at a better price then we were paying. I was so happy we switched our business insurance too. Thank you Eric
  • Avatar wendy demski ★★★★★ 3 months ago
    Kelly is fantastic! She is quick to respond, and so helpful answering all our questions. Added bonus, she’s saving us a lot money. Definitely worth giving Community Insurance a call and seeing what they can do for you.
  • Avatar Rick Daniels ★★★★★ 3 months ago
    Our Home Owners and Auto Insurance recently increased nearly twenty five percent. I reached out locally to Kelly at Community Insurance in Amherst WI. Kelly not only found a more competitive rate but better coverage also. I found Kelly … More very responsive, thorough and professional.I highly recommend you touch base with Kelly for your insurance needs.
  • Avatar Nicole langenfeld ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    I have only great things to say about Kelly and Community Insurance, they help us tremendously find affordable insurance for our vehicles and home.
  • Avatar Shawn Buchholz ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    Kelly Loken at Community Insurance is informative, helpful, prompt and professional. Her knowledge and customer service skills are beyond 5 stars. Not to mention, she is very involved in her local community which carries over with her kindness … More and involvement of her clients. I definitely recommend Kelly for your insurance needs.
  • Avatar Cayden Haferbecker ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    Kelly has been great with helping me shop for the best deals and has patience when I switch vehicles often.
  • Avatar Sandra Lynne Schmutzler ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    Prompt service and ready to answer all inquiries regarding both personal and commercial property. We like to be able to visit our agents and to develop a working relationship with both agents and staff.
  • Avatar cathy knetter ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    This is a great insurance company to do business with!!Hometown experience and personable.

Independent Agent vs The Rest.

Instead of just working for one company with limited offerings, we represent dozens of top rated insurers. As your needs expand and change we continue to find the best carriers at the best value.

Features & Services Our Agency Captive Agent Online & 1-800 Companies
Access to multiple companies and wide range of products
Easy switching from company to company without hassle
Unbiased and objective advice Tries to sell & support only their one company Tries to sell & support only their one company
Claims assistance and advocacy Adjusters are often exclusive to the one company No help: You vs. adjuster
Policy service from the same person you bought from To call center You'll likely never talk to the same person twice
When you buy from an independent agent like us, you're supporting local business and your local economy #choicematters #independentagent